The Ethical Barometer

Delivering the Homeless for Health Care and Cash

The FBI served search warrants on City of Angels Medical Center, Los Angeles Metropolitan Medical Center, and Tustin Hospital and Medical Center as part of a Medicare and Medi-Cal fraud investigation.  A lawsuit filed by the city of Los Angeles against the hospitals alleges that the hospitals recruited homeless souls, including drug addicts and the mentally ill, from Skid Row as patients.  The hospitals are then alleged to have billed government programs for phony care for these folks.  Indeed, one operator of a Skid Row health center is alleged to have accepted $20,000 per month in kickbacks for the Skid Row referrals.  “Human pawns” is the term the lawsuit uses in describing the use of the homeless in the scam. In exchange, the homeless received food, cigarettes, and cash for their round trips to the hospitals. Read more »

How Was I Supposed to Know What VIP Meant?

Senator Christopher Dodd, chair of the Senate Banking Committee, said he knew that he had been designated a “VIP” by Countrywide Financial CEO Angelo Mozilo (in street language he was an “FOA”, or “friend of Angelo”).  However, Senator Dodd said he had no hint that he was getting special treatment.

Meanwhile, Senator Kent Conrad, chair of the Senate Budget Panel, said that when he called his old friend Jim Johnson (former CEO of Fannie Mae) for advice on a mortgage for his Delaware beach house, Johnson put Angelo on the phone.  Senator Conrad said he was “unaware” of any favoritism in his loan until he read about the break he got in Portfolio magazine.

Senators, senators, when Angelo designates you a VIP and takes your call at the drop of a hat, you may have crossed a few ethical lines thereby trotting into conflicts of interest territory. 

You Never Know From Whence Good Information Will Come

The sordid tale makes you want to avert your eyes.  There is a terminally ill wife grappling with her husband’s public confession of an affair.  How that tugs at your heart strings!  But, you find you cannot avert your eyes because there are the journalism ethics questions, “How come The National Enquirer beat the major news sources to the story by almost nine months?  And why was it ignored until photos forced a confession?” 

The John Edwards saga has, at once, so much sadness and so much enlightenment. There are lessons to be learned from this tale of woe.  Some of the basic principles and lessons learned here could have been drawn from similar sagas that have run from Eliot Spitzer back to Grover Cleveland:  1.  Truth percolates.  It just wants out there. Behave accordingly.  And, if you slip, admit it, make amends and disclosures (particularly when in the public eye), and then move forward.  2.  Benjamin Franklin and the Hell’s Angels had it right:  “Three people can keep a secret if two are dead.” Read more »

Moral Equivalency and Barry Bonds

Leave it to Sports Illustrated to not understand the Barry Bonds issue.  Ben Reiter wrote, “If teams are rejecting Bonds on moral grounds, WHO ARE THEY KIDDING?” and  “Still, in a sport where teams happily take late-career chances on outcasts like John Rocker and men of advanced age like Julio Franco, there should be a locker for Bonds somewhere.” [Emphasis in original article, “Will Work for What He Made in ’86,” Sports Illustrated, July 28, 2008, p. 18.

Well, there is a difference between hiring a guy who mouthed off about subway riders (Rocker) or another who is long in the tooth (Franco) and a guy who is under indictment by the feds for perjury charges related to the steroids mess (Bonds).  We don’t yet indict folks for being less than PC, which Rocker was.  And thanks to aging baby boomers, we love to see the old duffers out there giving it the old pre-rest-home try.  Think Greg Norman at 53 giving the Scots great delight in the recent British Open.   Read more »

49% of managers uncovered a lie on a résumé

A CareerBuilder.com survey

38% exaggerated their former job responsibilities

And the survey of 3,000 managers found some whoppers:  Degrees from nonexistent schools and a claimed member of the Kennedy family.  Oddly, the Kennedys had never met him. 

Hasbro, Scrabulous, and the Bloggers

Scrabulous, the online knockoff of Scrabble, was shut down on July 29, 2008 because Hasbro, and rightfully so, pointed out that Scrabble, the basis for Scrabulous, was its copyrighted game.  Scrabble launched its own online game, but hackers made the authorized version inaccessible. 

Bloggers are howling about Hasbro.  Dear bloggers, proceed with caution.  Intellectual property rights exist to ensure that those who have good ideas are rewarded.  Scrabulous was nifty, but it was not original.  Hasbro may be late-to-the-electronic party, but circumvent intellectual property rights and you’ll find innovation suffers.  As I tell my students who continue their free downloads of copyrighted music, there are costs to freebies.  Don’t come running to me when all you have are merry jingles for music.  If you want angst, you must reward sweat of the brow.  If you want good games, you reward those who develop the game, not those who stand electronically on the shoulders of creators.  If it were your game, how would you feel if someone ripped it?   

Classic Quotes:

“Being 99% honest is no longer enough.”

Former presidential candidate, John Edwards, admitting to an affair

“Thus we mix good and evil, right and wrong and make space for the absolute triumph of absolute Evil in the world.”

Alexander Solzhenitsyn, in a speech at Harvard in 1978.

“[Expletive] to compliance guys.” “Business guys rule.”

Quotes from former employees of Indymac in Tripp et al. v. IndyMac et al, (C.D. Cal. 2007), including third amended complaint filed on June 6, 2008.

Indymac officials indicate that the former employees are disgruntled and that it was a victim of the downturn in the real estate and mortgage markets.

The Legal Round-Up:

Brocade Settles Options Backdating for $160 Million

Brocade Communications Systems Inc.  entered into an agreement to settle a class action lawsuit over alleged tampering with stock options.  Brocade will pay $160 million to the plaintiffs in the suit.  Two Brocade officers have already been convicted of criminal charges related to the backdating. 

Kwame Kilpatrick, Detroit’s Mayor, Not in Jail

The Ethical Barometer may need to get a changing number system in order to keep track of the legal comings, goings, and bond issues of Detroit’s mayor, Kwame Kilpatrick.  After serving an evening in jail for attending a business meeting in Canada, Mr. Kilpatrick will be back in court this week to determine whether he violated a court order that prohibits him from having contact with potential witnesses in the perjury case (perjury charges underlie the indictment, bond etc.).  Mr. Kilpatrick visited his sister, a potentail witness in the perjury case.  The assault charge arraignment is pending.  Mr. Kilpatrick’s lawyers will seek clarification about the mayor’s right to visit with family members who happen to be witnesses.  Stay tuned.

Kwame M. Kilpatrick, Detroit’s Indicted Mayor

Mayor Kwame M. Kilpatrick has his share of legal difficulties.  He is under indictment for perjury that relates to his testimony in a wonrgful termination suit of two city employees who had thrown down the flag on the mayor’s parties and extramarital affair.  After the two employees received $6.5 million in damages, the issue of perjury surfaced because of text messages uncovered from the mayor’s phone.  The messages were between the mayor and his former chief of staff, the alleged other party in the affair. The mayor had to spend some time in jail last week for crossing the Detroit River into Canada, all in violation of his bond/release restrictions imposed during his arraignment.  Whilst the mayor cooled his heels in jail, the attorney general filed additional charges of assault against the mayor for his alleged shoving of two officers trying to serve subpoenas on some of the mayor’s friends.  Also pending is a petition by the Detroit City Council to Michigan’s governor Jennifer M. Granholm to have the mayor removed for cause.  Governor Granholm has a hearing scheduled for September 3.  The Motor City has its hands and hoosegows full. 

Featured Books by Marianne Jennings

The Seven Signs of Ethical Collapse

Never trust the people you cheat with. They will throw you under the bus.

Not everyone has connected the dots on the patterns in ethical collapse. Ethical collapse is a state of moral malaise. Ethical collapse happens when organizations are unable to see the bright line betwee right and wrong. Now, there's help for keeping the line clear and bright - avoiding ethical collapse is possible. You just need to recognize the signs and get your antidotes in place.

A Business Tale: A Story of Ethics, Choices, Success

Meet Edgar P. Benchley. Charitable people tend to call him a nerd. Others use less subtle descriptions. If you hear Edgar chatting to himself, don't be alarmed. He has an invisible friend who's kind of a cousin to Harvey from the old movie of the same name with Jimmy Stewart. Edgar's rabbit, Ari, possesses many charms. Ari adores Aristotle and Peter Drucker, detests ambulance-chasing lawyers, is well versed in theories of moral development, and can't resist Godiva ice cream (Hey, even consciences have their weaknesses.)

A Business Tale is a delightful fable for all ages, including managers experienced and not so, that teaches that the seemingly high price we pay for honesty does bring tremendous payoffs in the long run. Includes "10 Pointers for Playing by the Rules" and a foreward by Dr. Laura Schlessinger.

Admin